Back to CardTrends

How CardTrends prices cards

One price per condition, from a fixed chain

Every card printing gets three prices: Raw (Near Mint), PSA 9, and PSA 10. Each takes the first source in a fixed chain that has a value. Nothing is blended and nothing is modeled.

Card pages also show PriceCharting's Grade 9 figure on its own line, labeled "Grade 9 · any grader". It mixes 9s from every grading company, so it is context only and never used as a PSA 9 price.

Where a card has PSA 10 sales but no PSA 9 sales, its PSA 9 page also shows an "Estimated PSA 9" ballpark on its own line, worked out from the typical gap between PSA 9 and PSA 10 prices of similar cards. It is labeled as an estimate, the PSA 9 price stays N/A, and it is never used in lists, watchlists, portfolios, or Market Movers. See how we estimate a PSA 9 price.

A sold comp only counts when its listing title names PSA and the exact grade, matches the card, number, and printing, and describes no defect. Lots, proxies, and foreign-language cards are excluded. If two prices on a card contradict each other (a PSA 9 worth more than the PSA 10, say), the one with weaker evidence is withheld rather than shown.

Evidence strength on every price

Each price carries a label describing the evidence behind it, never a model's opinion:

Priced high, in line, or low vs. its own sales

Where CardTrends has a card's completed sales history, the card page compares today's price with the median of that card-grade's sales over the previous 12 months. The price is "in line" unless it sits more than 15% away, or further when the card's own sales usually scatter more. A card needs at least 10 sales in the window to get a label.

This describes where a price sits. It is not a forecast and not a recommendation to buy or sell.

Track record

Because the band is a label, we check what happened next. At quarter-ends since the history began, every card-grade with enough sales was labeled using only sales known at that time, then measured over the following 6 months against every other labeled card at the same date.

Label at the timeCasesMedian move vs. other cardsShare that rose
In line with its sales299+0.0%87%
Priced high vs. its sales146-7.0%83%
Priced low vs. its sales9-4.7%89%

Read small samples with caution: Priced low vs. its sales has fewer than 30 cases, too few to draw a conclusion. We publish these results whether or not they flatter the label, and they update as history grows.

The CardTrends Index

The index starts at 100 in January 2023 and moves only on chained same-card returns: each month, every card-grade that sold in both that month and the month before contributes its change in median sale price, each change is capped at halving or doubling, and the index moves by their geometric average. Adding cards changes what the index can see, never its past level. Months with too few cards carry the prior level and are excluded from reported changes.

Latest level 313.9 (2026-08), +7.3% over 3 months and +111.2% over 12 months, across 2,970 card-grades.

Graded population

PSA and CGC population counts come from the monthly census PriceCharting publishes on each card's page, read whenever CardTrends prices the card. CardTrends keeps every census it sees, so a card page can show what changed since the last one.

Before a set's counts appear, they are checked against PSA's own CardFacts counts for the cards CardTrends has: a set appears only when at least 80% of those cards agree. Some WOTC unlimited printings fail this check, so their counts are held back, and a census far below the same card's 1st Edition count is held back too. Where that happens, card pages show PSA's CardFacts counts when CardTrends has them. Counts are for one printing and whole grades only. See the population report.

Coverage today, and what's next

Sales history, the band, and the index currently cover WOTC-era sets (1999–2003) in PSA 9 and PSA 10, from identity-matched PriceCharting completed sales through August 31, 2026. CardTrends now keeps every qualifying sale it reads, so coverage extends to modern sets as history accumulates. See the roadmap.